Clinical
Use Of XM-ONE® in focus
at ASHI symposium.
Impacting
outcomes in kidney transplantation: Non-HLA antibodies
and Clinical Risk Assessment
The
annual ASHI meeting was held in New Orleans, LA, and
attracted specialists within the field of
transplantation immunology. At the meeting AbSorber,
together with their US distributor Olerup Inc., hosted a
lunch symposium focusing on the clinical use of
XM-ONE®,
Absorber's endothelial cross match test.
The
Hopkins Experience With XM-ONE®
Dr
Annette Jackson started the symposium by reviewing the
experience at her lab at Johns Hopkins University in
Baltimore, MD. Johns Hopkins was one of the first
laboratories in the world to start using the assay and
was also one of six participating centers in the
multicenter study published in 2009 (Breimer
et al,) Dr Jackson and coworkers have subsequently
confirmed the findings in the multicenter study in a
single center extension of the same study (Jackson,
AM et al, Transplantation, 2011 Jul 15;92(1):54-60).
As in the multicenter study they observed a
significantly higher risk of developing acute rejections
among the XM-ONE® positive
patients. They also reported that these rejections were
cellular, with absence of complement activation.Dr
Jackson commented on the XM-ONE® test
procedure and stated that the advantages with the test
are that the method is easy, there is a strong relation
between anti endothelial cell antibodies and rejection
and that the antibodies detected are donor specific.
Limitations with the test according to Dr Jackson
include a high fluorescence background which limits
sensitivity, IgM interference, the fact that these cells
also expresses HLA, though to a lesser level than
lymphocytes, the requirement of fresh donor blood which
in deceased donor transplantation often not is available
and that the antigenic targets are unknown. Dr Jackson
is currently working with Stanford University, Stanford,
CA in the identification of non-HLA antigens via protein
array.
Introducing
the XM-ONE®
Proficiency Testing
Dr
Håkan Hall, Head of Research and Development at AbSorber
continued the discussion by reviewing the development of
XM-ONE® since the
initial research at Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm,
Sweden. This research was triggered by two young
patients experiencing hyperacute rejections in absence
of HLA antibodies (ref
Sumitran-Karuppan, Transplant Immunology 1997; 5:
321-327,). In 2008 XM-ONE® was
cleared for the US market by FDA and remains the
only FDA cleared transplantation cross match. In Europe
XM-ONE® is CE
marked including CD3 and CD19 enabling a simultaneous
T-, B and EC cross match in the same tube. In the US the
FDA cleared version is without CD3/CD19.
In
September of this year the first US external proficiency
testing (EPT) with XM-ONE® was
performed in the United States. The Clinical Laboratory
Improvement Act (CLIA) regulations require that all
clinical laboratories participate in an external PT
program approved by CLIA. The XM-ONE® EPT
methodology is approved by ASHI and CLIA. Five US ASHI
accredited labs participated in the Sep EPT and all
participating centers were graded satisfactory. The EPT
program will run twice yearly with the next EPT being in
Feb 2012. Centers interested in participating should
contact customer support at Olerup, Inc.
Ongoing
Single Center Study looks at both deceased and living
donor kidney transplants
Donna
Phelan at Barnes Jewish Hospital, St Louis, MO shared
data with the audience from their ongoing evaluation of
XM-ONE®. Close to
100 patients, 60 DD and 35 LD, have been enrolled in the
study. Due to initial problems with controls 77 (IgG)
and 89 (IgM) patients have been evaluated. Notable from
the demographics was that the XM-ONE® positive
patients were less sensitized than the negative patients
suggesting that the positivity was due to non-HLA
antibodies. Furthermore only 13% of the XM-ONE® positive
patients had a positive T-cell cross match.
In
the study a total of five grafts were lost thus far. All
of these patients were XM-ONE® positive.
The study is still ongoing but so far indicate that
XM-ONE® positive
pre transplantation correlates to earlier and more
severe acute rejections, and increases in graft loss
(5/5 graft losses were positive pre transplant). Two
important questions were brought to the forefront;
- Would
intervention based on positive result modify outcomes?
- How
can prognostic utility be improved?
Clinical
Case Reports
The
symposium concluded with case reports from the different
participants. A case of graft loss was presented from
Barnes Jewish. The patient, who was an AB to 0 LURTx was
HLA negative in both cross match and by PRA and was
treated with rituximab and pheresis to remove AB
antibodies and transplanted with a titer of 1:8. Shortly
after transplant the patient became anuric and a biopsy
showed AHR, C4d and arteritis. Isoagglutination titer
was 1:4 and HLA DSA testing was negative. The graft
could not be saved and nephrectomy was performed day 6
post transplantation. XM-ONE® test was
performed after the nephrectomy and showed strong IgG
positivity. The patient was successfully re-transplanted
prior to a negative XM-ONE® result
and standard negative cross match test.
From
Johns Hopkins a case with a male kidney transplant
recipient experienced three hyperacute rejections was
presented. The rejections all occurred within 12 hours
after transplantation and were C4d negative. Before each
transplantation the patient had been tested negative for
HLA antibodies against the donor but had shown
endothelial cell antibodies. At the third
transplantation the patient received extensive rescue
therapy with plasmapheresis, rituximab, eculizimab, ATG,
bortezomib and splenectomy but the kidney was not to be
saved.
At
Karolinska Hospital a similar case was presented, that
being an AB0i kidney transplant recipient with no HLA
antibodies against the donor (Ref: Holgersson, J et al,
Clinical Transplants 2006). However the patient had IgM
antibodies detected with XM-ONE®. The
patient was treated with rituximab, immune adsorption.
Nine days after the transplantation S-creatinine started
to rise and an XM-ONE® test
performed was positive but now for IgG antibodies. The
T-cell cross match was negative and AB0 titers were low.
Rejection therapy including immune adsorption was
started and after a week the S-creatinine was
normalized.
These
three cases all describe patients considered to be
"safe" for transplantation due to negative standard and
conventional cross match tests. Occurrence of severe
rejections in such patients are not uncommon and provide
a challenge to the entire clinical and laboratory team.
In these cases, XM-ONE® proved to
be a valuable tool in initial diagnosing the cause of
the rejection/graft loss both pre- and post
transplantation and also to be of value in choosing
therapy and/or in allocating the organ.
Please
also visit the AbSorber web site and find more
references on XM-ONE and endothelial cell antibodies here.
“AbSorber
is excited about the very positive interest that
XM-ONE® received
at the ASHI symposium, as well as the growing interest
in the transplant community around the world. It is
especially encouraging to see the clinical utility of
the assay being even more defined and that XM-ONE starts
to assists the clinical community in decision making in
organ transplantation” says, Anders Karlsson, CEO of
AbSorber.
XM-ONE® is a
standardized, cell based, crossmatch test for clinical
use. The use of XM-ONE® allows
you to identify patients with anti endothelial cell
antibodies, a risk factor for acute rejections in organ
transplantation (Holgersson,
S et al, Current Opinion in Immunology 2008,
20:607–613,). XM-ONE® provides
additional information compared to the currently used
lymphocyte cross match tests. For further information
see package insert or visit www.absorber.se.
For information, please contact:
Marc Vegh
Front Office and Laboratory Manager
MILAN ANALYTICA AG
Baslerstrasse 15
4310
Rheinfelden/Basel
Switzerland
fon +41 (0)61 845 99 88
fax +41
(0)61 845 99 87
e-mail: marc.vegh@milananalytica.ch
www.milananalytica.ch
|